12/11/2023 0 Comments Moab utah sceneryThey also allege that the plan violates the Dingell Act, which designated Labyrinth Canyon as a Wilderness Area in 2019. The BLM evaluated different alternatives and incorporated public comments into the finalized plan released in September. “A lot of the community made extensive comments and it seems like a lot of that information was ignored in the plan,” Burr said. They also argue that the road closures are “arbitrary and capricious.”įirst, the appellants argue that the BLM failed to take a sufficiently “hard look” at the impacts of the Labyrinth Rims/Gemini Bridges Travel Management Plan as required by the National Environmental Policy Act. How are motorized recreators challenging the BLM’s plan?Īccording to their notice of appeal, the BlueRibbon Coalition and Colorado Offroad Trail Defenders allege that the BLM’s road closures violate the National Environmental Policy Act, the Dingell Act, and the appointments clause of the U.S. The State of Utah and Grand County are still litigating their claims to these roads in federal court. The State of Utah and Grand County sued the Department of the Interior and the BLM in 2012 to settle the title to these roads under R.S. The BLM closed 114 miles of roads that were claimed as R.S. “This will immediately limit access by current lessees of the parcels and will undoubtedly impact ’s ability to successfully lease these parcels in the future, thereby negatively impacting ’s trust funds held for the benefit of the public schools and other beneficiaries,” reads the petition for stay. Those parcels are used to generate revenue for the state’s public schools and state mental hospital. The State of Utah says that the BLM closed roads that are necessary to access two parcels of state trust lands in Grand County. 2477 roads open, according to its petition for stay. Utah argues that the BLM “ignored” its requests to keep R.S. 2477,” a law that allowed counties to own roads built on public land. The State’s appeal against the BLM’s plan hinges on “R.S. (Christopher Cherrington | The Salt Lake Tribune) Why does the State of Utah oppose these road closures? The road closures outlined in the BLM’s plan will not go into effect until the board makes a decision. The Interior Board of Land Appeals has 45 days to make a final decision on the appeals. “There’s a lot of appetite for all groups that care about this area to go and help manage it and mitigate the impacts, and this plan really shut off a lot of that,” Burr continued. “This is a highly valued area for people for generations of all user groups.” “ definitely is hurting a lot of people,” Ben Burr, executive director of the BlueRibbon Coalition, told The Tribune. Separately, the motorized recreation groups BlueRibbon Coalition and Colorado Offroad Trail Defenders joined Patrick McKay, the vice president of Colorado Offroad Trail Defenders, to file a notice of administrative appeal and a motion to stay the road closures. The Utah Office of the Attorney General did not immediately respond to The Tribune’s request for comment. Redge Johnson, executive director of the Utah Public Lands Policy Coordinating Office, called the BLM’s plan “egregious over reach” in a Facebook post. Let’s advocate for a balance that respects both recreation and public access.” Spencer Cox joins this effort and is urging for collaboration. “Today, the Utah Attorney General’s Office has stepped in, petitioning for a halt on this plan. “Utah’s iconic Labyrinth Rims/Gemini Bridges region, treasured for its diverse motorized and non-motorized recreational opportunities, faces trail closures due to the Bureau of Land Management’s recent decision,” read a Facebook post by the Utah Public Lands Policy Coordinating Office. The IBLA reviews final decisions for the Department of the Interior. The State of Utah filed a notice of appeal with the Interior Board of Land Appeals (IBLA), as well as a petition for a stay of the road closures while the board reviews the appeal. “There’s a real dominance of motorized vehicle recreation, and this plan starts to create more balance in how public lands are managed.” “We really see the decision as long overdue to protect the Labyrinth Canyon corridor so we have some balanced approach to how public lands are managed in the greater Moab area,” Steve Bloch, legal director for the Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance, told The Salt Lake Tribune. In its plan, the BLM cited “known conflicts between motorized and non-motorized users” as a reason for some road closures.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |